It's been a while since I sent my works here.

So I wanted to work on my grass tiles again, I need some feedback on texture of grass and probably the colors.

Thank you. :)

Yeah that four leaf with two tiles were intentional, I thought it would make player see the grid just a bit more difficult. By the way, I made the tileset from scratch, here is the new one, I think I made it noisy again.



Edit: I forgot that I resized the image before I sent this, I apologize for that.

I sent the resized image unintentionally, I forgot that I resized it.

Try to avoid lone pixels, they tend to look noisy. Even 2-pixel lines are pushing it a bit. Commit to your grass blades - give them a cluster of 3+ pixels, or don't draw them. Approaching it that way should help you keep things clean.

Though removing the highlights did help reduce the noise a bit, it makes the grass feel blocky because the highlights - no-highlights boundaries are all straight lines. And there's still a lot of noise. If you're going to be selective about the highlights, maybe reserve them for only the largest, most prominent elements, and avoid highlights on the small bits of grass, since those are the ones that end up being 1-2 pixels big.

Not really a critique or hard suggestion, more of a "what if": Have you considered approaching grass not as a sequence of base - blades - highlights, but as base - blades - shadows (with appropriately changed colours)? Grass isn't very shiny, and having the grass blades be your brightest elements might help you avoid the tiny highlights. The shadows would still have some small clusters, but they'd be less prominent and could read more clearly as being overlapped by the grass rather than just noise.

Sorry to disappoint you, but this one looks worst of all, due to all tiles standing out, instead of blending together.

It's all good. I'll be working on it again at some point anyway.

I decided to work on my grass tiles again, dirt road on the right still needs work, but grass blades on the dirt road looks quite bad I know. Also remade all of my grass tiles and I need to know if grid is noticable here.