I'm going to take the first post to say that I think PJ has awesome smileys that need no revisions or updating (cept for kissy).

Not if it's a change for the worse, what kind of logic is that?

Anyway, I'm with jal on this. PJ has changed enough in the last year or so, these smileys remind me of the good ol' days when the OTT was but a babe.

As starter from the idea to change the smileys:

They look pretty standard, and do not have that much to do with PA as well..
And I think that you could have way better smileys, since there are artists in this place who have awesome skills.. And skills improve as well. I really think the new ones pie made by example are way better than those whe have now (also made by pie).. And yes, alot of the expressions are very cool, but they are a bit larger than the text, witch changes the size of the lines, and the colors could be less grey as well.. and I think that if you ask every1 to make a new smileyset, there will come a much better one..

I dont know much of the changes on PJ, since im a new member (februari I think it was that I joined), but I think those changes where made because the new things where better than the old things.. It all happens with a reason.. and since these smileys can be better, why dont we change? Those good old days cant be so important.. and if they are, im shure you can remember them without help of the smileys..

I say we open a poll voting, about if we do or do not want a new smileypack..

I've always thought a few pixels smaller would be nice, so when you used them in a big paragraph they wouldn't upset the line spacing.

The smileys at the moment are cool. But pie's are somehow better , just you cant really see the facial features.

I like dumbo's smilies, personally. They represent PJ.