With or without outlines?

With or without outlines?

You need to be logged in to rate pixel art.

 

Pixel Art Details

With or without outlines?



user
Title: With or without outlines?
Pixel Artist: Dhanh  (Level 1 Rookie :: 56 points)
Posted: 10/29/2013 12:05
Palette: 21 colors
Statistics:  8 comments    2 faves    0 avatars

Hi, this is my first post here and this is my first time working with pixel art so I´ll need all the critique and help I can get. ;)

I´m trying to decide the art style for a game I´m developping but i don´t know if I should go for the selective outline (that I find more pleasing) or if I should go for the solid outline (for better separation from background). The character will not be controlled directly (RPG commands style) so I don´t think separation will as important as the feel of the game.

I´m also open for any advice on the pixel art itself (characters and background) since I´m quite new to this. Thanks in advance!

 

PS: if anyone is interested in helping with this project just let me know, I´ll probably need some help.

Discussion

If you would like to comment you will need to be logged in. Register now. It only takes a moment and it's free.


user
Dhanh (Level 1 Rookie) @ 10/30/2013 12:54

Thanks everyone! As recomended I´ll try to work on the desaturated BG to create separation and go with the one without outlines (that everyone seems to prefer) even though it will be for a game. Will post it later today or tomorrow!


user
StoneStephenT (Level 8 Ruby) @ 10/30/2013 04:13

From an artistic standpoint, without outlines looks better.

From a 'this might end up turned into a game' standpoint, with outlines looks better.

They both look great, though.


user
failureboy (Level 7 Assassin) @ 10/29/2013 21:59

As stated, your issue I think is more about the colors needing to contrast so that the characters stand out.  Consider making them relatively bright over a darker, less saturated background.

Or just look at this stage from Samurai Showdown 3:www.substance-tv.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/Ss3genjuro3bg.gif 


user
JeffSturmann (Level 1 Private) @ 10/29/2013 17:19

very cool! but  i think that those white pixels in the trees doesn´t look so well.


user
Ellian (Level 8 Partner) @ 10/29/2013 16:18

Without looks better. 
It may not be as readable, though, so make sure you keep high contrast values between the background and the sprites!


user
Dhanh (Level 1 Rookie) @ 10/29/2013 15:27

Thanks! I´ll post on the WIP forums for the Work in progress or character studies. And the even though I agree that the outlined ones will stand out much better in almost any background the more I look at it the more I like the Non-outlined version... I guess I might just use desaturated colors on the background to work around this issue. But so far 1 point in favor and 1 against, I´m still considering the outlines as well. Thanks again!

PS.: I´ll post an animated version of them as soon as I decide the whole outline thing!


user
Squirrelsquid (Level 4 Rubbish) @ 10/29/2013 14:49

 if these are for a game, I would advise to go with outlines. should make it more easy to read against any background.

 


user
failureboy (Level 7 Assassin) @ 10/29/2013 13:26

be aware of the WIP forums; quite a busy place that is visited by some pretty good artists from this site.  That's where you'll get the best & most consistent advice.  the public queue is for finished stuff, typically.

I like the one with NO outlines better.  Cute characters, would love to see them animated.


Related & Tags


Game, art, samurai, japan, outline, selout, With or without outlines? avatars, With or without outlines? icons, With or without outlines? pixel art, With or without outlines? forum avatars, With or without outlines? AOL Buddy Icons

Sponsored Products

Donate

Want to give some dough back to all those amazing pixel artists? Donations provide prize money for contests, help cover hosting costs and support new initiatives.

Play party games with QuizBash app
Play party games with QuizBash app

Report Problem

If you are going to report an issue with this piece please provide relevant URLs/Images to back up your claim.

Register

If you would like to be a team player why not register? It's quick and easy and you'll be able to comment on, rate and upload pixel art.

Already Registered?