Xero's jealous because ryan made something better in five minutes than xero could make in like fifty days.

And that's a sweet as egg nvision \m/

You are all more than welcome to discuss each other's critique/comment styles in the "Diversions" section or just using PMs. I have no problem with people having a healthy argument, but it sucks to drag down a fun thread like this with a dozen posts of a discussion that has nothing to do with the thread.  If you would like to discuss critiquing/commenting further further I'd be happy to moderate a thread.   Btw, this is not to single anyone out... we've all had times where we get a little snippy with one another. 

OK, let's get this back on topic please.

People, can we see a bit more actual creatures and a bit less re-creating the egg and slapping some legs on it? For example is someone makes a green egg don't just make a green egg and put eyes on it. It shows a lack of creativity plus it gets very boring to see essentially the same thing just made by a different person.

Anyway, whipped this up in Paint in an hour (it shows ), 13 colours - his name is Lumpy! And he's sad because he doesn't have a girlfriend because he's ugly.

im gona have to back you on that one so-lou.

maby we'd see more, if it wasnt mostly flat colour. Its almost all purple and red.

The dots at the bottom seem randomly placed.

Well deal with it. o_0

I honestly don't know why you made it so big even if it is a trademark that your work is big or whatever....bizarre. Could've easily made it egg-size... ?

Okay now that my initial thought of holy crap it's ginormous has passed, I think the colours are a bit garish but I like the dithering style and the top of the egg's shape. It's a bit overwhelming looking at it so huge though y'know.

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA kirstie alley

sh*tty five minute egg. XD

Geez, talk about uptight. Re-post your egg and stop complaining about people's reaction to the size. If people are all making "regular" sized artworks and then someone walks in with this mother canvas piece, of COURSE people will say 'whoa that's big' before they even think about the colours, style etc. So calm down and get over it. Not a big deal. And it seems you didn't even read all the praise you got about the dithering style etc. What do you think Napoleon? "GOSH!!!"

Back on topic, I am pixelling some cross-breed creatures at the moment and more eggs as well.  Can't wait to see what everyone comes up with next.

And yes Saboteur, my egg's name is in my post right under the egg.

Saiklor: 'I didn't expect or desire for people to comment on the shading, this thread isn't WIP it's finished pieces for colab. and I don't see why my particular piece is now getting critiqued just because it's a bit larger than the other works.'

I just thought I would say what I liked about it after my comment of 'it's huge' because you seemed to offended that that was the first comment. So I tried to redeem myself by commenting about the other things other than its size. But there's no pleasing you.

Saiklor: 'Honestly, all other digital artists other than pixellers work MUCH bigger, so why do you all live in these tiny boxes? It can't be THAT shocking to see a piece of this size because compared to ANY OTHER FORM OF ART OUT THERE, it's still TINY.'

Pixel art is an artform that works primarily on small canvas's because essentially they are tiny dots put into place 'one at a time' and usually used for mobile phone games (small canvas), web graphic animations (small), icons (small) etc. Of course, comparing your egg to ALLLL the artforms out there, it will look small. But that's like comparing an abstract portrait to a real-life portrait - OMG ONES ALL FUNNY LOOKING AND THE OTHER LOOKS REAL. That's because they're from different forms of art. ;)

Saiklor: 'whatever, I've removed it, the thread can continue without the disgusting taint of my attempt at originality.'

And the oscar for the most dramatic performance goes to....  Listen, one, nobody even dissed your egg in the first place. Secondly, there ARE other huge pieces of pixel art out there. Splatpixels work for example. And you know what someone says to him? "Whoa that's huge" and he says "yes" and they say "huge and SEXY" - because they are. If you can't accept people's first reaction (which isn't even negative in the first place) then you might find taking actual criticism, even harder. ^_^

Now to try and make you understand the drastic action of your taking down your egg completely, here are some nice things said about your egg that you may have missed when getting pissed off for no reason:

So-lou said: 'I like the dithering style and the top of the egg's shape.'

Pixelblink said: 'Personally, I think it was cool. You've definitely your own style'

TakeOut said: 'Dude, it was fine I liked it. I loved the shading'

Lastly, Saiklor, I don't think my 'insult' of saying you behaved in an uptight manner by taking down your egg was in any way harsh, cruel or pointless. You really just need to laugh this off and acknowledge that you got offended for absolutely NO reason. I even tried to make my post sound upbeat with a Napoleon Dynamite quote. NAPOLEON DYNAMITE!

Aleiav worded my exact reaction to this. So please, Saiklor - I'm not trying to be vindictive or patronising in any way, and am simply trying to get you to lighten up. We all liked your egg!! So bring it back into this thread post haste. And someone will creature-ise it. ;)

Now back on topic (so sedge won't get the flying monkies onto us) Garage Inc. that is a fantastic little creature !! I may just have to cross-breed him with something! AND that ice egg is MIIINE!

pixelblink >