The chest size, while on the upper limit, is passable. If you don't need to fit multiple people (or stuff) in it, you can make it smaller.

In order to decide if you need to populate the tile, try to progress with it. The best way to populate it without overcrowding is to add rocks or flotsam.

WIP for 11

Thanks Hapiel, I will try my best.

You're still not really blending into the style of the tiles around you, it's very clear where the border is in all cases. You have a big advantage with the lighthouse, you don't actually have to resolve where the edges meet just hide it behind the lighthouse. I also think your water would look more spooky if it were a darker shade of blue. I would also consider making the rings on the water bigger they are a bit noisy with all the single pixel detail.

Thanks for the tips Reo, I will try to tweak it more.

I feel ready to get back to this! I know what to do for #30!

I got stuck, I think I need a break from it, didn't come together like I wanted it to. Have a much clearer idea for this one.

Rs11_s21_N; your colors are all wrong, otherwise, the tile is good.

it's ok?(11)

So... Reo's reservation of tile #61 has expired (after a century more or less)... :D
I think I'll try to do something with that tile, if nobody is against it. :)

@Rs11_s21_N Very nice. A lot of details. I like it: is it Earthworm Jim? :)

@Arkan go ahead!

@arkan85; yeah well there wasn't any traffic back then, also he had a pretty looking WIP so I didn't delete his res although he told me to. Now that he's chosen another tile, it's yours :)

@Reo; I liked the zeppelin idea a lot, would you consider doing it elsewhere?

Awesome would like to see that :)

Definitely better than before :D

I used tinypic to upload the images in my previous post and I think the service is down at the moment.
I can't use imgur since it's blocked in Turkey so I am trying a new service called ImgBB, hope it works.

Update WIP for #7. Slowest edits ever.

Decided to try populating my treasure chest boat with a few people and a stereotypical big guy to justify the large pants used as a sail (don't worry, he won't be naked lol, I'll give him a nice pair of underwear). I put the big guy on one side and several people on the other to try and make sure the boat looks stable and not like it's about to flip over due to the big guy.
Would appreciate tips, suggestions, and of course critiques. It's been a long time since I've last done a tile and I'm still re-familiarizing myself with ISO collabs, so I'd be happy if someone could oil my rusty old parts.
Also right now I'm juggling between being busy and forgetting about my tile (but I do my best to get back to it), so I may be slow with updates or even end up posting after the 7 day mark.

woot tintin and haddock, awesome!

Going great Arkan

Finished #7 edits

Sure, let's do that :) I'll work off your edits.

And here are mine :) Definitely looks better this way!

So.. I haven't joined the last few colabs. but I couldn't resist seeing what would happen if I let Photoshop use Content-aware fill for the empty tiles…

Consider this Photoshops entry into this :P

https://imgur.com/NqrhtSP

I would like to take 37 if that is ok.

Still trying to work on my tile. I've made a little progress but it's nothing significant, as I've got various distractions such as college and drawing for a site that take me away from doing the tile :(
I also kind of feel pressured with the 7-day time for reporting stuff, I can't always post within that time period due to the aforementioned things and just generally forgetting to let you guys know. I know that in the past this was instead two weeks rather than just one, could someone remind me why the time was reduced to 7 days again?