Thanks for the advice! I'm bad at shading cloth tho.

I think this is your strongest submission yet! The post reads well, and the design's cool. The scuthe handle seems to be missing an outline pixel near the hand though, making it blend with the cape. The cape also feels a little flat because there's no shading on it.

When you choose highlight/shadow colours, don't just make them darker/lighter versions of your base colour. Change the hue as well - that'll make them look more dynamic/interesting. If you shift all the shadows towards a single hue, and the highlights towards a single different hue, that can also help unify your palette, so that all the parts of the image appear to exist in the same space, to be lit by the same light sources.