perfect, i like it

Yeah the rocks were intended to be from a 'ruins' level, hence the smoothness and clean lines across some of them.  I'm sure if I made a full scene for them they would seem much more appealing, but alas no time right now...

good not great, the texturing is ok, but yes it can be interpretted as somewhat smooth. but they are the kind of rocks that you are suppose to look at once and not stare at them because if you do well it takes the greatness a way but adds so much greatness when added in with other things!

I disagree, I think these are just fine. The texture and modeling are great; these rocks look smooth and igenous, like they're in a damp cave.

very smooth rocks.. Some of it even looks flat. I think you could of done better than what you have there zeid.