i'd buy it just for the g&w keyring.

Well, G&W is LCD graphics, so not entirely ;)

I like it more now too, you really captured the pixel theme in this.

Done. I like it far more now.

Well, it will not hurt if you'll backup and try how it will look like. And then decide.

Do you think it'd look better if I moved the "Inside" tag to the left, facing the mascot?

its pretty good, and I like the logo, but I agree with a.b.lazer that the right side seems a little empty compared to the left.

 If you'd used your own palette I think this could be much much better.

Hmm... I like it. It has great logo, proper background and character features cartoon hands and face. I'm not too keen on form and placing of 'inside' table (it makes left side full and right empty) and form of bowl, but I think it's of the better entries.