Does not need to be redone since you just made a version of his avvy and did not rip it. That said, I would never use this as a guide to your skill and talent.

this just begs to be redone properly. and i hope you do so.

well it was rushed, as i said i almost missed his birthday so i do admit i could have done a far better job on this. i didn't really know how to stylize the text at the time so that's why i went for something simple.

as part of it being produced in a rush, i couldn't get a good looking skull and crossbones so i included SF's jolly roger sprite that's part of his username (that seemed a good idea asit's intended as a gift for the man himself). here's the original, as you can see little was changed.

SF obviously has no issue with it since he's even using this as his avatar but i do realize it might be a bit of an issue here. should i remove it?

The type ruins the piece. Your aa could be improved, here it looks kinda rushed. Nice otherwise

Just askin'..what does 'edit of SF's' mean?