Lovely! Removing the black outlining would improve it, though. Also, I think the bottom part of the rose should be darker (more in shadow), considering the highlight on the top part. It would give it more depth and shape. Nicely done, though, I like the shading on the toothed thing on the left.
I love the textures, the thorns, the bumps, the smooth petals - good job!
thanks for the advice, will think about it next time .-.
thank you thank you.