it's great how you used just 3-4 color tones :)

The neck is funny, and I like the laser sword :)  4*

 I really like the tone of the darker shade +W+

The arms look a little odd. Nice piece though.

I want to say that I love the effect on the lightsaber-esque sword.  The only weird thing to me is that there is blue light seemingly coming from behind the pirate even though the blue sword is in its hand. 

I like the bent pegleg.

nice, good job

Excellent! Great color use.

Nitpick: the bottleneck conflicts with cloak details.

Delightful colors, great design and lovely style. This is pro.