thanks alot for the review and comments.

to be honest the tiny version was actually made for a trial game but i got carried away and gave him a sword made him throw daggers and all that and there are too many sprites to edit them all. and as i said it is my first pixel art and in the big version i wanted to show where he carries daggers/items so i added a bag. the fingers do look bad so maybe i will tidy it later on.

thank you =D

 This might be a bit nit picky, but I'd like to see an attempt at pixeling  the shoulder bag that the detailed sprite has on the in game sprite. I think it'd help with the consistency between the two. 

Welcome to PJ, hope to see more from you. :)

Very good for a first piece, the detailed image has some bits you could tidy;

The hands/fingers of the right hand particularly could be tidiet. The end of the right sleeve where it meets the hand should be rounder to show its wrapped around the hand. The little sprite is very tiny, maybe add a red pixel or two for the neck area (triangle) of the scarf.