good mock up i usally dont like mock ups but this one is good

Very nice job on the wall.  I like it.

Sorry dudes. Seeing as how this is old and crusty now, I can't really be bothered going back. I'll keep in mind the crits if I ever do tiles again though.

I love the table, fireplace, door and sword.

Tiles are incredibly hard to do.  I would say get more diversity and detail into it.  No one wants to look at half a screen of wood planks.  Make different kinds of wood, a few more rugs, some items on the floor--perhaps plants, or a pile of books.  There's a lot of unused space.

Still, I could never hope to do anything like this.  I commend you.

Not bad. the textures on the wood (not including the wall) are great. I think that the sword could have a more metalic feel to it and that the fireplace looks missplaced as the wall gets lighter to the top and the fireplace is a part of the wall and the fireplaces is pretty much the same level of darkness all the way up..