Meh, I looked closer and the left legs are fine, it's just the right legs and the lack of movement elsewhere. Plus you put up a good argument so I give in, 5 stars.

Of course they are from scratch, i wouldnt post an edit on a portfolio site

and they bend their knees a bit, remember they are walking, not running, i dont know if you bend your knees much while walking, but i dont.  perhaps they could bend more, but i dont really see the point when games like FFT get away with not bending

ill take all this into consideration when the coder decides to actually do what he says hell do, until then theres no point in working on this project anyway

They're not even bending their knees!?! If you made these from scrathc, then 3-4 stars. If you edited them, 1 star.

good but could be better

these are supreme, but BOB is right, their 'right' legs seem a bit longer, and kind of static and limpy.

I personally would make the heads bounce on the shoulders a bit.

Once again, very cool to the "T"...but considering this a place for critiques I have to say something about it. The biggest problem with the animation is that each of the characters "fore-legs" seem to be longer than their hind legs( I know they just look like that from the viewers point of view...). It also looks like the characters suffer from Al Gore disease(i.e. unbendable limbs) of the legs. it's as if their legs were made of wood, and they can't bend em'. But the designs, mind you, are still top notch, and worthy of bieng put in a game...