Thanks for the comments everyone :)

Yeah, the composition isn't very good in this, which is a result of being rushed XD
I may go back and fix it later.

I think the composition would benefit from the removal of the light sources from the frame.

It doesn't say it has to be depicted but nor does it say it shouldn't be.

Goodlyay has a point about the crampedness of the picture. It never said anywhere in the challenge description that the light sources had to be depicted in the picture, so they can be offscreen if it works better that way.

Name made me lol...

I like it a lot, although I feel like it would have been better if the candle and especially the fire were just a bit further away from the pumpkin. Right now it looks a bit cramped.