Almost there, nearly can't see the disappearing coz he comes up too fast. That final part of the move should be sloooow.
If you want this to read as a toaster, there must be more exaggeration, delay, recoil. Toast should lag behind and get out of the toaster during the fall, and almost disappear into it at touchdown.
Yeah, the animation looks like it's skipping in the middle. Just here to add my two cents.