A silouette dose'nt have to be black.

http://filesmelt.com/downloader/Patamon31.png

The hole of the image basicly jumps around from a black outline to a dark coloured outline, stick with one or the other and it would look better.

I like the colours of the sky, the rest is boring tho.

There is a purple outline in places where it dose'nt need to to be e.g the speech bubble and santa's side leading into space.

Overall I like it well shading and a witty idea.

Smooth animation, but the shading could be more dynamic when the fire appears. Very well done.

I like the animation, but some of the shading moves in a weird way.

On the neck area the out line seems to change colour and it looks weird.