True, yet we're not getting an update from him for the last 134 days :/

You're welcome :)

You have done a great job and have truly made an effort, kudos :)

...you have 2 stray pixels (pink).
Also, unless you are sick and tired already notice your angles could be slightly better, in an iso way. If not for the isometric perspective your eye is just fine, k.

Notice too that there is more detail at the base of the eye you could add too. Its cool if you want to use my ref edit if you need. Try not just to copy me or anyone else. Think about why a pixel is being placed...

Jalonso, I even tried to improve my tile, but what I did only made ​​things worse

Gecimen I did not understand what you talked

Sure!

@JuninFC, your tile is improved don't worry. I'll post an edit about what I mean with "rail".

here is the tile, you do not know why, but I thought the other was better
(I speak through so awkward is because I use google translator)

It's pretty good, but I think you should use the same method as used in the statue, on the rocks, and I did not understand much the statue on top, her body is inside the water?

@wuhu; this works pretty well. The only thing you should remember is you're not limited by the tile borders on the lower side (since yours is an edge tile). Not much to criticise but I would maybe color the left foot a bit lighter to make it look more seperate.

@Jalonso; awesome, just when we needed more tentacles!!!

@JuninFC; Just please edit this perspective issue and you're done. It really ruins the tile. Also fixed the colors.




Edited by Gecimen - 20 April 2011 at 5:33am

@Jalonso; My favorites are:
1- 3rd one in first row (this is absolutely amazing btw, little people hanging around in a Smurfs-like environment)
2- 4th one in first row. I like this one because of the mysterious glow in the middle.

I'm not talking about the pixel job, but about which concept would suit better.

And no, don't think something big hanging freely would look that good.

I agree with JuninFC, the computer room also seems like a cool idea and continues the Fallout theme. Still the other 2 is good too.

Also I've got this idea, dunno if it can be applied.
When the last tile is left, shall we make a challenge of sorts (maybe a weekly challenge) for that tile and put the winner in place?


Edited by Gecimen - 21 April 2011 at 5:02am

Nice job wuhu. I don't see much wrong, cept the water dropping off the cliff could be offset with dark grey to set them into space.

...speaking of space



Edited by jalonso - 21 April 2011 at 10:42am

here's my tile, I modified one that Gecimen did and I thought it was better than before

Do you mean this tile is what Gecimen made or you made it using his as a reference?

I misunderstood your comment. I am sorry.

Not sure what you mean, but i suppose you mean adding dark gray around the tips of the water, so we can also see them better on white background ?





Thanks in advance,

@Gecimen : Alrite, deciding which one..hmm

Can i try #23 ? I can go out of the border to the right yes ?

Update on main pic with wuhu and JuninFC.


...


@JuninFC, You have been a real trooper picking up that mini-collab tile. It was probably not a very creative output for you so maybe after that tile you can make one more where you can put your own ideas or vision down freely. Of course help, advice and c+c will remain the same.

@wuhu, 23 reserved for you.


Edited by jalonso - 22 April 2011 at 10:58am

Umm.. yeah I'm speechless... pouring so much ideas in 1 tile...

Edit: double post due to connection error.


Edited by Gecimen - 23 April 2011 at 2:59am

Go with the UFO or tentacles or computer room or glowing mine thingy???

Castles, villages and things like that break the rules for this collab. I will have to make a new tile. This collab is underground theme. Its all in the first post in the rules.I just forgot :/

You can still have #7.

...star trek :/

Jalonso , I did not understand, you want me to improve what?

@JuninFC, from this point on, it's not about making an OK tile, but improving your technique. In order to do this, people can make edits on your tile, and you may learn some stuff by comparing them to yours.

For example, in this edit below, I removed some outlines and changed some shading issues in the eye.

Now compare this with your tile, and see the difference.
If you like it, examine how it's done.
If you don't like it, just ignore it.

There's no forcing in this, do it only if you want.

(Tried to write in simple sentences.)