Hey ya'll. It's been a little while. I've gone back to mostly programming instead of creating more art assets so I haven't really been around as much lately other than lurking about looking at stuff.

I had the urge all of a sudden to do a group pixel art pic of my favorite gaming website crew and thought I'd ask ya'll pros if you have any suggestions or notice any glaring errors. I think I'm definitely currently using more colors than I should but couldn't get things to even remotely look right w/out expanding the shades.

Also, I'm color blind, so I'd really appreciate it if someone could tell me whether or not the skin tones are totally jacked. Thanks =)

The one in the brown is sorta just hands on hips. Is it the coloring that makes it hard to tell? Should they be brighter?
I see what you're saying about the arm being too straight but he's actually holding the guitar behind his head so his arm is sorta supposed to be like that. I could try fidgeting with it. Maybe extend a single row of pixels to the right?
And the guy next to him, you can sorta tell what's up w/his hands better if the other one isn't in the way. I could try scootching him over so that you get to see the pixels that are hidden behind the straight arm. thx =)

Looks better, but maybe you should lighten up the shade on the hands, for the man in brown make his right hand larger. Also I just noticed that they have no feet.

Tried lightening the hands a bit and increased the size of the man in brown. Also. . . added feet.

There's more than just some anatomical issues here -_-;; I originally started it as sorta a big head, mid body, small legs but then started adjusting more towards realistic proportions. . . The adjustment wasn't completely successful =\ I think I'm going to have to rework the brown guy's left arm as it does look too short. The pink dude's hands were sorta fixed up a bit and added a little more shoulder though, he's a really skinny guy so it should be super small, but not nonexistant =P

Thanks for the continuing crits. I hope I'm putting them to good use -_-;;

I like it a lot!  It has a super deformed feel with the enlarged heads/shortened bodies, noticeably Brad and Jeff, but it captures their personalities well.  The light sourcing seems weird because the light is coming from everywhere (green screen setup/studio) but the dominant light is behind them (shadows of the characters coming forward).  Reflected light wouldn't be nearly as apparent as it is in your piece I don't think.  Ryan looks almost shiny (although this too may be accurate to life :)

By the pose he's putting his weight on the left leg and the right is bent slightly.  I dunno, it looks okay to me.  The only thought I have is that the shin area looks pretty thin for his bodysize, and his right foot seems narrower than it should be.