Hey @DevastationNation thank you so much for the in-depth comment, as I am at the beginning of learning pixel art, this comment is very appreciated. I think I agree with most things you said, and I will take next week to update the character based on the comments and see what happens. (I usually don't update them but will this time!)
I agree. The dragon's solid, and I kind of wonder if it'd be a stronger piece with the dragon as a standalone.
Let's start with what's working for Bubblegum here.
The hat is excellent, needs 0 work
The collar and sleeves of her shirt work
Her waist, arms, and hands look good
The rifle's missing the hand part, but still works excellently aesthetically
The legs themselves and stockings look good
As for things that are throwing me off:
Her hair looks kind of like spaghetti that's been painted at the ends - it clumps together like a mop, and I suspect this is because of 1. a general flat contrast when (especially bleach) blonde hair tends to highlight on edges and ends and go dark between valleys (example: https://media-cldnry.s-nbcnews.com/image/upload/newscms/2016_19/1084171/summer-hair-color-today-160511-tease.jpg ); you've got some of that going on with the pink, but I'd darken the darkest hue on the pink, too
Continuing on the hair - there's some style inconsistency in the level of colors it has (4 colors vs 3 on areas that take up more space and attention), and I think you could toss out Shade 2 on the pink with only improvement (I'd say tossing out Shade 3 on the stockings and trading it for the knee shade would make similar improvment, too)
The breasts received too much shading focus for what they're probably actually doing: I'd nix the wrinkles in the middle and just leave her left as it is
I don't know for certain if the shirt drooping back would make more visual sense if the breasts were simplified, but I suspect it wouldn't; if I were you, I'd hitch it up to where the second gray shade starts on her right bottom side of it and sharpen the edges of the shirt to communicate t-shirt/dress shirt rather than sweater heaviness in the material
For the skirt ... I'd clean up the lines, a lot - straight, no wobbling, for the kind of material a pleated skirt is likely to have; I like what you did with her right edge of it, but I'd firm up the left side at the "band" by having it more straight/up and down than the lower
I'd get rid of that garter entirely, or thicken up the top from our middle-left onward to match consistency with the rest of it; there's various shading choices you could make from there, but as it is it just looks unfinished
There's a stray dragon pixel to our left that's just kind of driving me crazy
The face is hard to say because the hair looks so thick it kind of puts the shape of her head in question; the eye patch doesn't really look functional or stylistically appealing either - I'd make it bigger, strappier, or nix it and fix the eye under it
I think the shoes work fine as they are since they're not a major focus of the picture, and I really like what you did with the tops of the stockings to emphasize their conformity to her legs
I like the way you signed and the simplistic lines, but the + signs in the upper right take away from the coherence of the design
Want to give some dough back to all those amazing pixel artists? Donations provide prize money for contests, help cover hosting costs and support new initiatives.
Hey @DevastationNation thank you so much for the in-depth comment, as I am at the beginning of learning pixel art, this comment is very appreciated. I think I agree with most things you said, and I will take next week to update the character based on the comments and see what happens. (I usually don't update them but will this time!)
Will keep you updated!