ironic in that the character in the avatar is called carnivac but you weren't to know that :P

anyways sorry to the picture poster for the bit of spam.

My bad.  I was going by the icon.  SEEEEEE.  My name changed, but no one is confused >:C

Finally got my name changed and you call me by the other one. tsk.

 The outlines on the coral are a little odd, and I think the background would benefit with some more detail, but yeah overall I really like it.

grass is too blocky.

but everything else is just loveable. :D great job with limited pallete.

Tiles are nice, but the coral blocks makes it look messy and cluttered as Wolv said.

It's ok but the use of those very blocky looking tiles makes it look rather cluttered

Aw man, sorry about that it's a habit of mine from doing mockups for games. I was thinking about my entry when I was coming home actually, and I remembered "Oh crap! I put a black border!" D:

Anyway, fixed. And I'll probably add some more enemies/objects. I'll also try to make the crabs better. Thanks!

Please either remove the black border, or replace the border colour with a colour from the challenge palette. Once you've done this resubmit. Thanks.

Yeah, crabs seem to be a bit rushed and could use some more lovin', but the mockup as a whole is ace. Love the sunken ships.

waw! I'm against this?!

Splendid details. The drowned seafarers will rest in peace knowing their ships are supplying a fine backdrop. ;P

It's a shame those pesky crabs have to be so sloppy, though.