This is one of the few mockups I have ever really liked.  Some can be good, nice, OK, but this one is great, it's so nice to look at.

 How about a compromise - you could remove the animation everywhere but the face!  Because I like the face animation.  I think he's had too much cocaine.

 I have a fantastic idea but it's doubtful I'll do it because I'm a lazy pixeller :/

 *hisssssss*

 Nice creative shading technique.  I think it could use more variation in the hues of the rocks, and more contrast.

I just made this color edit really quick.

img59.imageshack.us/img59/4289/quickeditcolor.png

I didn't really put a lot of thought into the new colors I picked, and I am by no means a color expert.  The point I'm trying to make is, you can make pixel art a lot more interesting if you use more than just the luminosity slider when you pick your colors.

 This is nice.  I only wish there was a bit more contrast to the colors, though, because at a first glance, it's hard to read what's going on.  The border looks like it was mind-numbing work.  Good job.

 I'm really glad pop-ups seem to have gone away.  I only get them very occasionally.

I like this.  Nice detail.

 I think this would look a lot better with smoother lines.  Try to AA the crap out of it.

 Thanks :)

My mind was kind of running in cycles at the time I started it.  I couldn't get around the fact that life probably has no meaning.  Also, I had just broken up with my girlfriend and wasn't sure I did the right thing.

 All of it's fantastic.  I like all of the colors...except the brown in the sky.  The brown in other places works fine, but the brown against the purple is kind of bleh to me.  That said, I am completely biased and the color brown is by far my least favorite.

I wonder if the buildings could use a softer outline.  I think I'd like it either way.

 I never really understood why this thing has so many favorites.  Submit it today under a different name, and I wonder how well it would do then.

It's not bad.  I just don't particularly like it.

 This is real nice.  Although I'm not sure about the brown in the rose.  I think maybe another color could have worked better, but brown is my least favorite color, so I'm biased.

 Am I the only one who saw this and immediately pronounced it "Mount Paint?"

Also, I just tried it, and found that my lines would not be continuous if I drew them too fast.  And, unfortunately, "too fast" is really kind of slow.  That's a huge turnoff.  I'm sticking with regular paint.  I don't need any mountains, anyway.

 Wow, this is neat.  It looks like it was pretty repetitive to make, heh.  I like it.  The only comment I have is that it's maybe a bit too uniform.  

I look forward to seeing more from you :D

 Dude, this is awesome.  I wish I could make this.  I love this kind of abstractness.  And the C64 colors are really nice here.

 bahaha, way to use the red XD

I like it.

 Ah, the sky looks much better now.  I really like this, especially the colors.  You have good artistic sense.  I have the feeling you'll be a really good pixel artist.

 Unique colors.  I like it :D

 I love colorful stuff.

 This is really interesting.  I like it.  I sorta dislike the outlines, though.

 Well, the highlights seem like they're in weird places, the fingers are jagged and oddly shaped, and it kind of doesn't fit with the rest of the body; maybe there needs to be more black on it.  It really doesn't bother me that much, though, and I could just be commenting on stuff that's intentional.

I like the eyes the way they are, by the way.  The face is my favorite part of the piece.

 Cool stuff.  I like it.  Creative :D

The hand might be a little bit jacked up.

 Haha, I like it :D

 Thanks!  :)

 Eh...count me out.